Stimulant medications and automaton kids: Sociobable or substantive concern?
It is fashionable in some domains of public discourse to denigrate psychostimulant medications and their therapeutic impact on young people living with ADHD. In particular, it is not uncommon to find armchair philosophers, scientologists or even research naïve journalists happily spouting off about the way that psychostimulants turn young people into robots, take away their feelings and generally make them less than human. These medications are, in the mouths of those espousing such opinions, at best dehumanizing and perhaps worse. They are supposed to take away the mind and the soul of those to whom they have been prescribed. They are supposed to make young people less authentic as individuals and are supposed to block their ability to make critical considerations about their ability to function, on or off the medications. In short, they are a challenge to authenticity and damage moral agency. An interesting aspect of this pontificating has been the strength by which ...